WASHINGTON
(AP) - A federal court judge on Thursday ordered the release of U.S.
documents that may clarify the role of former U.S. Vice President Dick
Cheney in the exposure of the identity of former CIA agent, Valerie
Plame.
But U.S. district judge, Emmet G. Sullivan
also determined that there were parts of the document, which quoted
from an FBI interview in 2004 with Cheney, should remain confidential.
As
thick as a 67 page document has to do with the leak the identity of
Plame, an incident which led to an investigation process that dragged
the former Cheney chief of staff, Lewis Libby Jr., on charges of lying
to the grand jury court.
Watchdog group,
Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington (The group Citizens
for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington / CREW), fighting for the
document through the application of freedom of information law (FOIA), a
case which was opposed by the Justice Department during the reign of
both Obama and Bush. The
case has put the Obama administration in a contradictory situation,
having to defend Cheney, who is a critic (the government) the most
tenacious.
On Thursday local time, the Justice Department said it was studying the decision issued by Judge Sullivan.
Although still unknown whether the Justice Department will file an appeal, the department shall immediately make a decision. Judge Sullivan ordered that the document should be released on next Friday.
In
ordering the release, the Judge Sullivan rejected the argument that the
Justice Department said that the document remain confidential thirsty
because of the disclosure documents are only going to make White House
officials during the next administration is not willing to cooperate
with criminal investigations.
Judge
Sullivan said that the Justice Department adopted the argument would
require him to create a new law, a job that calls can only be left to
Congress.
"However, this court is bound by
the law is still valid, that does not give sanction to the understanding
of the statute that way," wrote the judge in the rules.
But
Judge Sullivan did manage that portion of the disclosure document must
remain secret because the executive exemption rights, national security
and privacy in the FOIA law. Among these exceptions, there is a setting documents relating to the internal deliberations among senior White House official.
The
judge did not give details about how much that will be used, although
he said that there are only two sentences relating to "confidential
communications" between Cheney and former President who will not be
published.
CREW Sullivan praised the judge
for having rejected several arguments raised by the Justice Department,
but CREW also expressed disappointment because there are parts of the
document which will remain confidential.
"The
high government officials should not be allowed to hide their behavior
from public view," said Melanie Sloan, CREW's executive director. He
called on the Justice Department to really take advantage of President
Obama's promise of greater transparency by releasing the documents that
may be suppressed voluntarily.
The note is part of an investigation process known as "Plamegate" (Plame scandal).
Libby
is the only one who faced lawsuits as a result of these complicated
circumstances, even though he was not actually charged with leaking
section. Former President Bush commute Libby's prison two and a half years before Libby undergoing imprisonment.
The
scandal has its roots in a state address in 2003, where Bush said that
Iraq's former ruler, Saddam Hussein, had tried to buy uranium in Africa.
Plame's husband, former U.S. ambassador, Joseph C. Wilson IV, denied the claim. Rebuttal
that - according to Plame and her husband - resulting in leaking the
identity of Plame as an undercover agent to the late columnist, Robert
Novak, as an act of revenge.